Blogs & News

Two men tragically died in upstate New York after falling into a manure tanker, a stark reminder of the lethal risks associated with agricultural environments. The incident occurred at Champion Farm in Kirkland, New York, situated less than 50 miles east of Syracuse.

The sequence of events began when 33-year-old Nathan Doody attempted to retrieve a piece of equipment that had accidentally fallen into the manure tanker. In a devastating turn, Doody lost consciousness and fell into the confined space of the tanker. Tyler Memory, aged 29, heroically rushed to his aid but also succumbed to the toxic fumes, collapsing into the tanker alongside Doody.

Manure, as it decomposes, emits several hazardous gases, including methane, ammonia, hydrogen sulfide, and carbon dioxide. These gases pose severe health risks when present in high concentrations. Methane, for instance, is highly flammable and can displace oxygen in confined spaces, leading to asphyxiation. Ammonia, in sufficient amounts, irritates the respiratory system and can cause burns to the eyes, throat, and lungs. Hydrogen sulfide, notorious for its rotten egg odor, is deadly even in low concentrations, causing rapid unconsciousness and respiratory failure. Carbon dioxide, though less toxic in small amounts, in high concentrations can lead to suffocation by displacing oxygen in the air.

The tanker's confined space exacerbated the danger, allowing the gases to build up quickly without adequate ventilation. This deadly combination of gases likely led to the rapid incapacitation and tragic deaths of Doody and Memory.

Upon realizing the gravity of the situation, workers at Champion Farm immediately called emergency services. Firefighters and paramedics responded swiftly, but the rescuers faced significant challenges due to the toxic environment inside the tanker. Specialized equipment and protective gear were crucial to safely extract the victims.

Despite the best efforts of emergency responders, Doody and Memory were pronounced dead upon arrival at the hospital. Autopsies were expected to confirm that their cause of death was asphyxiation due to inhalation of the toxic gases.

The Farm Safety Association underscores the danger posed by manure gases and emphasizes the importance of proper safety measures and training for agricultural workers. These incidents serve as poignant reminders of the hazards inherent in farming practices, especially when dealing with confined spaces and decomposing organic matter.

Tragically, similar accidents have occurred in the past, highlighting the ongoing need for improved safety protocols. In 2016, a Wisconsin farmer and 13 cows died after being overwhelmed by methane or sulfur dioxide from a large manure holding tank. In another heartbreaking case, an Iowa father and son perished after being overcome by fumes in a hog manure pit