Blogs & News

In today's world, where artificial intelligence tools like ChatGPT can generate text for us, one might question the necessity of learning to write well. Despite the advancements in AI, the ability to communicate effectively through writing remains crucial. Good writing not only clarifies and enhances messages but also reflects positively on the writer. This article explores the perspectives of various high school students on whether learning to write still holds value in the era of AI, considering practical, creative, ethical, and future-oriented viewpoints.

Practical Benefits of Writing Skills

Effective communication is a fundamental skill that extends beyond academic and professional settings into daily life. Writing persuasively or analytically helps individuals articulate their ideas clearly, whether it’s through emails, text messages, or face-to-face conversations. Writing fosters self-sufficiency and independent thinking, which can be undermined by over-reliance on AI. Jordyne from Ellisville emphasizes that writing teaches us to think for ourselves, a critical ability in an age dominated by information.

CC from San Luis Obispo County points out that while AI can be a useful tool, it cannot replace the confidence and articulation developed through practice. Writing is more than just a mechanical skill; it involves organizing thoughts and presenting them logically, which are essential skills for personal and professional success.

Creative Expression and Personal Satisfaction

Writing is not just about conveying information; it’s also a form of personal expression and creativity. Aditya from Hinsdale notes that AI-generated content lacks the unique perspective and authenticity that come from an individual’s own writing. The process of writing helps individuals develop original ideas and gain a deeper understanding of topics.

Aidan from Ellisville highlights that creativity, rather than grammatical correctness, is what attracts an audience. Writing allows people to express their emotions, thoughts, and creativity, something AI cannot replicate. This sentiment is echoed by several students who believe that writing brings personal satisfaction and a sense of achievement.

Ethical Considerations and Academic Integrity

The use of AI in writing raises ethical concerns, particularly in academic settings. Jeo from New York warns against the risks of plagiarism, stressing the importance of producing original work. Ariel from Miami Country Day School suggests that while AI can assist in understanding complex problems, credit should be given where it’s due, just as sources are cited in traditional research papers.

Liam from Glenbard West High School argues that while AI can handle grammar and spelling, the true essence of good writing lies in organizing thoughts cohesively and presenting them thoughtfully. AI’s tendency to fabricate information further underscores the need for human oversight in writing.

AI as a Complementary Tool

Many students recognize the potential of AI as a supportive tool rather than a replacement for human effort. Sam from Hinsdale believes AI can help create outlines and solve problems but should not be used to complete entire assignments. Zach from New Rochelle High School finds AI helpful for generating ideas and refining language but stresses the importance of human input for accuracy and quality.

Francisco from Miami Country Day School sees AI as a solution to the common problem of starting a writing task. By generating rough drafts, AI can help students develop their ideas, making the writing process more efficient. However, the ultimate goal remains to produce original and thoughtful content.

The Future of Writing in an AI-Driven World

While some students predict that AI might eventually take over many writing tasks, others believe that human creativity and authenticity will always be irreplaceable. Zack from Hinsdale Central views AI as a tool that, like previous technological advancements, will make certain tasks easier but will not eliminate the need for human writers.

Beau from Glen Ellyn acknowledges the growing competence of AI but believes that students will continue to value their own learning and understanding. AI may assist in the writing process, but the ability to convey unique ideas and emotions will remain a human domain.

The Uniqueness of Human Creativity

Several students argue that AI will never fully replace human writers because of the unique qualities humans bring to writing. Liam from Hinsdale and John from Glenbard North HS both emphasize that AI lacks the ability to replicate human emotions, thoughts, and individuality. Writing is deeply connected to human experiences and emotions, which AI cannot authentically reproduce.

Stella from Glenbard West and McKenzie from Warrington, PA, believe that creativity, critical thinking, and emotional intelligence are inherent to good writing. These qualities enable writers to connect with readers on a personal level, something AI cannot achieve. The art of storytelling and persuasion is rooted in human intuition and empathy, making human writers irreplaceable.