Valerie Fennell and Deb Kuminkoski, who had originally planned to attend former President Donald Trump's rally in Butler, Pennsylvania, opted to observe from Valerie's backyard due to the intense heat and crowded conditions. Positioned in a grassy area between the rally site and the AGR factory, they unexpectedly found themselves in harm's way when the shooter, positioned on a nearby rooftop, opened fire towards Trump and his supporters.

According to their firsthand account, what started as a peaceful event quickly descended into chaos when attendees noticed a man with a backpack on the roof. As confusion ensued, gunshots erupted, prompting attendees to alert law enforcement. Valerie's son, present with them, witnessed the unfolding events, including law enforcement snipers taking positions to respond to the threat.

Despite their close proximity to the rally, Valerie and Deb observed a concerning absence of visible security measures in their vicinity, expressing surprise and dismay over the inadequate perimeter security. Reflecting on the incident, Valerie expressed shock that authorities did not initiate contact with her, given the proximity of her residence to the event venue. She had anticipated some form of security presence or communication, which she felt was lacking.

Recalling the aftermath, Valerie and Deb highlighted minimal visible security and the unimpeded movement of individuals within 150 yards of where Trump addressed the crowd, with only a sparse presence of local police vehicles nearby. Their observations pointed to potential lapses in security protocols outside the designated event area.

Responding to inquiries about security shortcomings, Kevin Rojek of the FBI's Pittsburgh field office acknowledged an ongoing investigation to assess any deficiencies, emphasizing the Secret Service's responsibility for overall event security, including external perimeters. Lt. Col. George Bivens of the Pennsylvania State Police recognized the challenges of safeguarding a public venue against determined threats, despite significant police resources deployed.

Valerie and Deb also provided photographic evidence highlighting security vulnerabilities, such as a makeshift barrier secured solely with zip ties between the shooter's position and the rally grounds. Their detailed account and documentation vividly illustrated the events and raised serious concerns about safety and security in their community, leaving them deeply unsettled and reevaluating their confidence in local security measures.